Counter proposal for scoring:
-Each game gets 1-5 points according to how much we've seen before. 1 pt for new trailer for something we've seen tonnes of up to 5 for something brand new.
-Each game gets 1-5 points for hype/nicheness. Indies get 1, a new Zelda/Uncharted etc gets 5
-Each game gets 1-5 points for how much is shown. 1 point for tease, 5 points for gameplay demo/trailer
-Each game gets a point for each of the following:
-Release date
-Release date in 2014
-Hyped reaction from crowd
-Super hype reaction from crowd
-Playable demo at home
So each game shown gets between 3 and 20 points.
Overall presentation:
-One point for each non-gaming feature announced
-One point for each joke that hits
-One point for new DLC announcements
-Extra point if the DLC doesn't look to be a shameless cash grab
-Minus 5 points if the DLC is for a game that hasn't been released yet
-Minus one point for each joke that misses
-Minus one for each delay
-Minus one for each back pedal
-Minus one for each cringe moment (game failures, obvious actors etc.)
Seems fair to me, and keeps focused on games. (I say fair, but Microsoft seems to like the cringe moments and bad business practices that the presentation points penalise)







