By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
padib said:
spemanig said:

There is no theory. There is no opinion. It's fact.

You didn't give fact. What you are saying is completely false. You can't be in a sleep for 10 years and wake up more adult. That's a lie. It's incorrect. Your brain obviously changes as that time passes, but without experience, none of that morphology means anything. You're making the bowl bigger without adding more water into it. Infact, the opposite would happen. Your mind would deteriorate and you would lose basic skills such as speach and memory.

Again, you find me one example, just one, of someone waking up from a coma and acting their new age. I will eat all the crow in the world. We're arguing facts, and you are wrong.

Since you provided no sources, I went ahead and looked it up.

Among the results, I found a 3 year-old girl who picked up a strange smoking and beer downing habit upon awakening from coma, a croatian girl who woke up speaking perfect german after a 5-day coma (unable to speak german anymore) and a kind-working grandad who became a crazed sex-addict.

You're pretending like the brain does nothing while in coma, that's not an idea you can convince me of.

A person waking up 7 years later in a coma without suffering a seizure is not the same person upon waking. Though they might be confused for a time, their brain is not the same at all.

Even worse, a woman who was 32 before her coma suddenly thinks she's a teenager and forgets she's married and has kids. So an adult can be a child?


None of that has anything to do with the topic. You're citing cases of short term comas and brain trauma. None of those people "grew up" after years of being in comatose, which is what you're arguing, and which is still false. A three year old smoking isn't her growing up, it's bad parenting.