By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
bigtakilla on 23 May 2014
Edit Thread
sc94597 said:
bigtakilla said:

They didn't like Windwaker's design nothing new about that, and still can only be speculatory. 

So the guy didn't like TP, point still remains. 

3D OOT is a remake (remakes always get lower scores) people didn't ask for that made changes that were unnecessary. (Same with Wind Waker, got a 90 where the other got a 96)

We could also look at the numbers for Skyward Sword (7.9).

All your points seem to be arbitrary as well. 

Actually Windwaker's User Score is 8.9 (original) vs. 8.8 (number of reviews can make a huge difference, especially since they're rounded to the tenth's place.) 

You still haven't explained Majora's Mask (9.2), A Link Between Worlds(9.0), A Link to the Past (8.9), and  The Minish Cap (9.1) in your theory that child link must mean more critical acclaim (assuming your criteria.) There are so many factors involved in a Zelda game that it seems so infinitessimally unlikely that the age of link matters.

That is true, I was looking at critic numbers unstead of users, but that doesn't change the end result. 

Those scores for the other games look pretty good to me. I was comparing worst and best, and stories involving young Link tend to be more acclaimed.

If you want to compare the entire series of young Link to adult Link that's on you, go ahead. I can safely say that outside of remakes the young Link series has always been better recieved than adult Link. That's a statistical fact.