I use gamerankings.com, which gives a nice idea of how good a game is and I select some reviews of sites I know who at least explain why they give a certain figure.
For normal reviews I usually pick IGN. And for RPG's I usually also pick a RPG ite like RPG Fan.

The Patapon forumtopic: http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/thread.php?id=14103







