Would you want a Smash clone for "mature" characters?

[Areym]

Mr Khan said:

Areym said:
I'm all for it but judging from All Stars sales, it's probably not profitable outside of Nintendo. Granted, All Stars was not perfect or better than the Smash bros franchise, but it was still a great game. A great game nobody bought.

It needed a more focused character selection. Spike, Sackboy, Toro, the medieval guy whose name eludes me atm, even folks like Sweet Tooth, Drake, and Nariko were okay. But Big Daddy, wtf?

Indeed, that was its greatest downfall. From those commercials with all the characters in it, you would think they got everybody imaginable but not being able to include insta-classics like Crash, Spyro, Cloud, etc was a huge letdown.

Still, I don't think the success of Smash Bros can be replicated.