Xbox One isn't Number One, but that does not equal 'Doing Terribly.'

[Euphoria14]

Carl2291 said:

Euphoria14 said:

Understood, however if there is strong and obvious evidence to show that the current numbers shown on the front page are incorrect, based on months worth of NPD data, then what exactly is the end game for this thread?

Do we now say people can't come in and completely disprove what the OP is trying to brush off as fact? If the proof is there then there is no wrong in them using it to argue against the OP.

If people want to bring up other trackers, sure. I have no problem with that. 

I dont like seeing people bashing VGC numbers without basis, though. As Vitro says, on a Weekly basis we have nothing from NPD. All we have is Monthly totals. We have no idea what stock levels are like, we have no idea if the PS4 takes a Month thanks to a single big shipment.

Shitting on VGC numbers just because simply aint cool. Vitro is clearly talking about Weekly numbers, and there is no doubt at all with what we have available that from time to time, the Xbox One has indeed outsold the PS4 in America since launch.

Weekly for not, going by NPD #s of the last 3 months we can't exactly trust what is shown here. That is why these threads won't go anywhere.

If VGC continually shows XB1 winning weekly and then NPD shows PS4 won for the entire month then how does anyone determine which weeks it won or didn't actually win?

 

Personally I don't really care, but I easily understand the argument the non-believers are bringing to the table and I do find that they have basis.

Want it to stop? Then have ioi make changes or at the very least address the obvious issue.