Ethomaz's Dismantling the Myths: Amazon.com's Best Sellers is Not Accurate to the Predict Overall Hardware Sales in US (Checking: Accuracy with Software)

[Kasz216]

ethomaz said:

Kasz216 said:

Except Xbone is 16.

So you are saying that "Brother: Tale of two Sons" sold more then the top Xbone SKU  when it's 3 month average before that has the game selling about 12,500 copies a month?

 

The fact that the numbers don't show the numbers is a reason why you actually haven't shown it's accurate.

You showed for 8 months it got the placing right... not that for 8 months it got the actual sales right.

 

If you take the list as total sales, Xbones sales should of been FAR lower... or Brothers should have released a huge press release for it's GIGANTIC and unprecedented sales surge.

(and god knows what the Wii U's sales would look like.)

You know Xbone sold 140k in January, no? So it is not impossible that Brothers outsold it in PC digital.

140K is likely more then the game has sold total for PC.  Look at those numbers up there again.

They're actually worse then the ones i listed up there because it's 4 months instead of 3 months.