no they should keep the kinect. It has its uses within the UI and some games ,, plus its selling much better then the 360 in the same time . Considering its only available in 13 countries ,, cost 500,, i would say the console is selling pretty well. MS just needs market kinect is an accessory to the controller rather then a controller replacement. For example ,, talking GPS in NFS . Its handy as you do't have time to check the map. Stuff like that kinect will work very well in.