archbrix said:
There is no way anyone could tell that SS does anything better than MK8 based on that screenshot compared to this one: The reflections in the SS shot look like crap. It looks nothing like the game does in person, which is my point. |
No you're absolutely right about that, and I didn't want to take this argument to an extreme of claiming you can tell everything form a crappy screenshot.
My point was about things that are much more obvious, like for example from the videos in the OP you can see that characters & scenery don't seem to reflect in the water. It's not a qualitative thing, or something you need to have insider knowledge to know, it's a "can you see it or not" thing.
This screenshot... well things look nicely environment mapped and it looks gorgeous. I can't really say it needs gen 8 hardware to do it or not though. We can assume that it's pushing Wii U's GPU hard therefore it would need to be cut down to work on PS3/360, but it's hard to see something that would make it impossible to run on that 7 year old hardware.