EDGE gives Yoshi's New Island 4/10 [62 on Metacritic]

[kekrot]

JazzB1987 said:

The art-style alone robbes 25% of the games possible MAX score.
So it cannot get better than 7.5/10 even if the rest would be perfect.


Btw  exactly this is how I  feel about 90% of all the studios that are NOT Nintendo.  They just dont know how to make games. Even if they get a 9 out of 10 (because their publishers bought good review scores etc) all the games just lack polish and soul and feel rushed.
(my latest 2 games are Diablo3 and GTA5 and there is just so much wrong with those 2 games....)

I completely felt that LuigisMansion 2 was NOT a Nintendo game. It was an okayish game  but LM1 was FAR better.

I know how you feel, but then over 90 % of the studios that are not Nintendo are shovelware studios :P

I thought LM2 felt like a Nintendo game, but with western influences maybe? At least it was thousand times better than NSMB. The multiplayer in LM2 was really, really fun too, me and my friends still play it...