The art-style alone robbes 25% of the games possible MAX score.
So it cannot get better than 7.5/10 even if the rest would be perfect.
Btw exactly this is how I feel about 90% of all the studios that are NOT Nintendo. They just dont know how to make games. Even if they get a 9 out of 10 (because their publishers bought good review scores etc) all the games just lack polish and soul and feel rushed.
(my latest 2 games are Diablo3 and GTA5 and there is just so much wrong with those 2 games....)
I completely felt that LuigisMansion 2 was NOT a Nintendo game. It was an okayish game but LM1 was FAR better.








