Are Game Reviewers unable to Review Wii Games?

[Bodhesatva]

No, my point wasn't that, Gotcha. I will make my point using two statements:

1) People who read video game magazines generally are hardcore gamers that have the same tastes as the reviewers, who are (by and large) hardcore gamers themselves. You made this point, and I generally agree with it.

2)  Users who write reviews on metacritic are usually people who also read professional reviews on metacritic. I have no proof of this, it's simply logical.

In other words, it stands to reason that the people who write user reviews on meta critic are precisely the same people that gaming magazines target as readers. And these readers seem to believe that Wii Sports is a significantly better game than most critics do. Ergo, critics are not doing their job properly since their professional reviews diverge significantly from the opinions of their readers.