no one game would appeal to everyone and be perfect to every gamers desire. Not even genre here but some game lengths are things that can't please some people, some people would want a perfect experience to end before it over stays its welcome the way Portal 1 did, some critics will say too much of a good thing will damage the mind blowingness of how great it really is like... Portal 2.
So yeah... don't believe you could make a game to please all, Ever.
edit - if a game got 100% from like... the first 50 review sites you know that site number 51 would know they could get so much ad revenue by giving it a 40% and reviewing it shit, it could be the last time people visit the site but people wouldn't be able to not go to their site just the once to flame them.
Why not check me out on youtube and help me on the way to 2k subs over at www.youtube.com/stormcloudlive
