EssosDeeos on 15 March 2008
The problem with the concept of a contrary column is that is forces the writer to lose perspective. It is like most 14 year olds attempt at critique - they do not have the skills to be objective and can only write a list of what they don't think they like about the game.
Uncut Magazine ran a similar feature a few years ago called "Sacred Cows" which put up clasic albums for the same treatment; it didn't last very long. It did however get reactions in the letters pages very similar to this thread which is perhaps the whole point.
It's a wind-up, not a critique!
