By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
nataraj on 08 June 2007
Edit Thread
Blones said:
nataraj said:
Blones said:
Escherichia said:
Ron Paul want's to abolish income tax. On one hand I understand why this is a popular idea, on the other hand I can't help but think that this would result in the worst economic nightmare this country has ever known.

Abolishing the income tax, along with the Federal Reserve, would be one of the best things that could happen to this country. First of all, the federal income tax is completely unconstitutional. Second, it doesn't pay for a damn thing. 100% of what is collected goes toward interest payments on the national debt. How would leaving money that doesn't pay for anything anyway in the pockets of Americans hurt the economy?


Why is federal income tax "unconstitutional" ? Do you mean it was created by an amendment - so its unconstitutional ? Well then, freedom of speech is unconstitutional as well.


 No, because the Supreme Court has ruled it so.  Originally, the Constitution provided for direct taxes, which are divided equally amaongst the citizens, and indirect taxes, which you can avoid buy not purchasing the taxed item.  The income tax is neither of these.  Now, most people think that the 16th amendment granted Congress the power to levy income taxes, but this is not so.  In the case of Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co., the Supreme Court ruled that "the 16th Amendment conferred no new power of taxation."  Furthermore, in the case of Doyle v. Mitchell, the court defined the word "income" in the 16th amendment as meaning corporate profits, NOT personal wages.  It's perfectly legal to tax a corporation's profit, but not an individual's earnings.


If you guys (I'm assuming you are a libertarian - just as Paul Ron is) think this is the case, why not put another case and stop Federal taxes. Beleive me - I'd love for that to happen. Would save me a bunch of cash !