By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

GTA IV [PC] (I found the story and characters completely unappealing despite the characters earning a lot of praise among gaming journalists. I also found the game to be just another run of the mill GTA, nothing to get THAT excited about.) My score: 7.5/10 GameRankings 9.7/10

Heavy Rain [PS3] (You take a mediocre and poorly written thriller, and mix it with a quick time event fest, and apparently that equals pure genius. I'm glad people have picked up on this with Cage's latest title and didn't just shower him with undeserved praise again.) My score: 5/10 GameRankings 8.9/10

Tomb Raider [PC] (Lesson of the game: Women can only be strong if they are broken and nearly raped first... such a disappointing and poorly executed origin story for a Lara. At least her hair was pretty!) My score: 7/10 GameRankings 8.7/10

Assassins Creed [PC] (I could not stand the hub world segments, they broke the experience for me. A friend had to convince me to continue onward to AC2, which I was glad I did, but my love for AC comes and goes with each title.) My score: 7/10 GameRankings 8.2/10

I don't think there was another game that I would consider overrated. Most others lived up to expectations fairly well.