Erhm, I'd have to go with:
1) The Last of Us
2) The Last of Us
3) The Last of Us
4) The Last of Us
5) The Last of Us
I played through that game TWICE to make sure I wasn't missing something about it that would make me mentally dethrone Uncharted 2 (yes 2!)... But nope, it was just not that impressive. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed it, and though it was a somewhat overly cinematic experience, the rest of the game just didn't fit right. I was EASILY the strongest man in the room halfway through the game, and since dying had zero consequence, I felt like I was playing (not "playing") just another generic zombie shooting game. The cinematic experience was the ONLY thing I actually felt redeemed it. Outside of the cinematics, it's essentially entirely forgettable...
Edit: Typo, lol
