In no particular order.
1 Wii Sports. outside of bowling these games kind of controller like crap. I guess people didnt care about controls? I would put the whole series here, but Resort was a massive improvement, and Party was ok
2 Smash Bros. Brawl, a game with that crap of an online shouldnt get the praise it did
3. GTA4 nuff said.
4 Xenoblade, i get it it was a well done JRPG on consoles at a time where the genre took a nose dive but its so boring. Ni ni kuni, Tales of Xilia are both better. Hell Graces is better.
5. Crysis 2 this game glithced out the ass, but that was the 360 version dont know how well the PC did in comparison