The reason the game is hyped in the first place is because of all the great word of mouth the game has been getting. I mean it got best game of E3 2013 and got dozens of awards. There were many people that tried it at E3 and said it was the most fun they had with any game. It's ridiculous to ask if a game deserves the hype it's getting after that.
Comparing this game to Haze, I mean really? Could you list all the awards Haze got and all the people that said it was their favorite game of E3? The situations between the two aren't even remotely the same.
Here's my main way of deciding if a game is overhyped: if the game had average graphics would people still be raving about it? Take Killzone Shadow Fall for example, if it looked like Titanfall would it have gotten any hype? The fact that Titanfall isn't being praised and hyped because of graphics pretty much tells me that it deserves the hype it's getting.
