JoeTheBro on 14 January 2014
| Best Story | Best Soundtrack | Best Ending | Most Addictive Gameplay | Best Multiplayer | Most Difficult Gameplay | Best New IP | Best Sequel |
| Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag | Bioshock Infinite | Bioshock Infinite | Diablo III | Battlefield 4 | Diablo III | Beyond: Two Souls | Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag |
| Beyond: Two Souls | God of War Ascension | Ni No Kuni | God of War Ascension | Grand Theft Auto V | God of War Ascension | Dragon's Crown | Bioshock Infinite |
| Bioshock: Infinite | Hotline Miami | Tearaway | Gran Turismo 6 | Killzone: Shadow Fall | Hotline Miami | Ni no Kuni | Grand Theft Auto V |
| Grand Theft Auto V | Rayman Legends | The Last of Us | Grand Theft Auto V | The Last of Us | Killzone: Shadow Fall | Puppeteer | Metro: Last Light |
| Metro: Last Light | The Last of Us | Hotline Miami | Knack | Tearaway | Ratchet and Clank: Into the Nexus | ||
| Ni no Kuni | Minecraft | The Last of Us | The Last of Us | ||||
| Tearaway | Resogun | ||||||
| The Last of Us | The Last of Us | |
