gamrConnect's 300 Greatest Games of All Time

[outlawauron]

Final-Fan said:

outlawauron said:

Final-Fan said:

I mean, I could surely quibble about the order of some of them, or the absence of others, but I wasn't surprised at the presence of anything but Uncharted 2 in the top 20. 

Why is that? I don't really like reviews, but it's one of best reviewed games of all time and the fan reaction is even better (Uncharted 2 is one of ten best reviewed games averaging 9.6).

I played it, I enjoyed it, but it didn't grab me the way most of the other stuff in the top 20 did.  It's a great game, no doubt.  But for me, it didn't have the special excellence a game needs to be that close to the top of a list of all-time great games.  Maybe I would change my opinion if I played it again.  Or maybe if I played some of the other ones, I'd change my opinion in that way.  But for now, that's what I think. 

I understand, but I would only put a single game (outside of Uncharted 2) that is listed in the top 20 in my top 50. It works that way for others as well.