Actually, looking at the metacritic list it's not that bad really. Half the reviewers so far have it at 7/10 and up, and on an honest scale (which all the next gen games seem to be getting so far) 7/10 is a good game. Then you have a couple who say it's bad, and several who rate it between mediocre and ok.
Like I said, still look forward to playing it. Hopefully I'll be one of the people who enjoy it.