The Last of Us.
Great game overall, but not the masterpiece it was touted to be. The story really drove the game, but the actual gameplay suffered as a result. Partners could walk around screaming at you, while you're trying to remain hidden, yet not alert anyone to your presence. Sequences giving you unlimited ammo broke the immersion. Death was a minor inconvenience at best, instant respawn took away from the survival-horror aspect of the game.