1) Mass Effect 3 (nothing to do with the ending)
2) Dragon Age 2 ( a good game honestly if it was a 10 hour game, but the recycling, and calling it something different is unacceptable, and unbearable after seeing the same dungeon someone elses house for the 100th time)
3) Bioshock Infinite-A good game, But an above average shooter with Great Art Design, that's tonally inconsistent. Makes it a good, above average game. But it's on this list since it's rated so high
4) MGS4-Nanomachines! This is a good game for what there is... except it's horrid pacing and imo, crappy plot twists and basically going in every direction I didn't want the narrative to go into, and ruining meryl's character arc making her marry captain indigestion, turning raiden into an annoying but decent character into an invincible ninja... and nanomachines. Not a bad game, but since it was rated so high, it's on this list.
Ofcourse stating the obvious that you guys fought over... it's my opinion
