windbane on 04 March 2008
| ZenfoldorVGI said: @naznatips I understand, and not to lessen this scolding in any way, but I just wanted to say, your the Commish to my Batman. @Riot Comeon man, don't sell me lies. You can't seriously believe that graphics should be compared between consoles when handing out reviews. If they were, then no Wii game's graphics should ever rate above a 6, no PSP games graphics should rate above a 3, DS a 2. Even if you wanted this chaos, you can't have it both ways. You can't have a FPS on the 360 rate above a 8 in controls after the mouse and keyboard were introduced, or after Metroid Prime 3. Your not seriously thinking this through, if that is what you believe. Graphics, controls, ect, they must be relative to the other titles on the hardware they are produced for. Ports and multiplats are exceptions on occasion, but they also prove the rule, that you can't say that Ninjabread Mans graphics are better than God of War PSP's graphics. It's the flaw in your logic that gets me, and what I believe is that you KNOW about this flaw, but are trying to work around it in your arguments. Dunno why, but I believe its because you don't think a Wii game should get as high of a graphical score as a PS3 game. It makes sense at first glance, but when your reviewing a game on the Wii, you can't bring console wars into it, that's just not how reviews are meant to work. Give the hardware a bad review, give the games developed for it a fair shake, or your not doing your job, that's how I feel about it. Sorry for calling you a dumb bastard, btw. I get carried away. |
Actually, Mr. Hates Sony Consoles despite owning a PS3, some PSP gams such as GoW:CoO and FFVII: CC look better than a lot of Wii games so far. I agree that graphics scores, for those peope that give them, should be relative to each system. Stop attacking the PS3 to make your point. If you can't find a quality game on the system: sell it.
