Who thinks the Halo franchise is over rated?

[selnor]

As a Halo Fan, and Sci fi fan I'll say that Halo is just awesome.

Apart from the first game it may not do anything new, but it perfects what it does.
It doesnt do anything wrong.

Also as a sci fi fan, It's one of the best stories I've seen. Ok so it borrows from some films, but it's so engaging.(Read the books to). I always loved Halo for the single player first and Multi second. Ive never been bored of Halo 3 single yet. I must have done it like 30 40 times now. It is sometimes hard to put your finger on why I like it.

I bought The Orange box. As it was my first time playing Half life 2 I thought it was good, But in places it felt like a chore. The graveyard bit should have been left out.
My point is for me Halo is more engrossing. A story thats properly consistent throughout the trilogy.