Instead of buying 4BONE, why not buy a Wii U this holiday?

[Max King of the Wild]

happydolphin said:

Max King of the Wild said:

Sure, a false dilemma is when you say something like "I can sit here and talk to you on VGChartz or I can go to school." It's a logical falacy because I'm sure we can come up with many other things I can do. For example, I can go fly a kite. By my original statement I misrepresented my options.

Now, in your case you are saying the only reasons ClassicGamingWhiz has not to buy a Wii U are the ones he listed therefore a PC is suitable for him. But as I have already done there could be more reasons than that. Just because he hasn't explicitly stated any other reasons doesn't mean there isnt anymore

I understand, but since those are the reasons he stated, I assumed those were his strongest arguments. You can't blame me for it. Otherwise, why did he not mention the actual differentiators?

And to flip your argument on its head, you are also giving him quite the benefit of the doubt.

I don't blame you for it. it's a fine counter argument. But you cant expect him not having a reason to not get a PC. Especially since he was only responding to the OP which is Ps4 vs X1 vs WiiU. He may have a completely different reason why PC isnt suitable. Since he hasn't responded we kind of need to give him the benefit of the doubt until he responds. After he responds and doesnt counter your argument then we can determine if PC is his best option