Battle Of The BEst GTAV vs LAST of US

[Mr Puggsly]

A_C_E said:

Wasn't TLoU's longest cut scene like seven minutes? As for action, there aren't many games with as tense of action as TLoU, especially on Survival, where a couple of hits kills you or one bite from the infected and your dead automatically TLoU is challenging for beginners on easy difficulty and its even more challenging for experts on Survival. Most games nowadays guide you through the storyline but with this your basically told the controls and your on your way through one of the best strories ever told in gaming, but that is also just my opinion. A game is supposed to be engaging and captivating, TLoU perfects both these by offering very believable, non-hollywood like characters who are put to the test morally, emotionally and realistically while at the same time offering the consumers a beautifully horrific atmosphere to trudge along in. The gameplay matches up with everything so well. ND just can't do wrong in my eyes.

GTA does the same thing  for the main storyline. My only beef the game since I'm a completionist is the setup of everything that isn't story related. It all feels tacked on, even if it is fun. I enjoyed tennis, but only for an hour, I enjoyed golf but only for a game. I could say this about everything in GTA 5. But at the same time, all those little things add in about an hour of gameplay so its not a total loss, plus its fun to cruise around in LS and do random shirt. I like GTA, I just don't think it compares to the quality of TLoU, like how TLoU doesn't compare to the quantity of GTA.

There are scenes much longer than 7 mintues that are heavy dialogue or have you exploring some boring area to solve a boring puzzle. He said TLOU had tight gameplay, I don't consider that very tight.

Bear in mind, I didn't say GTAV doesn't have slow moments. I don't feel either game can be considered tight.

I'm not interested in your nitpicking by the way. Ultimately, GTAV is more fun and offers a lot more value. So its my pick for GOTY.