By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

pezus said

stuff about Pokémon in a discussion with some other people and then, together with others, made a conclusion about the series declining.

To be fair, you can't really conclude the series declining though, because there isn't enough to compare.

Generation on generation, Pokémon sales have indeed went up: the first game on DS, Diamond/Pearl, outsold the first game on GBA, Ruby/Sapphire.

Of course it's not unnatural for a game newer than another to have lower sales due to legs, so it's no surprise Black/White has sold less than Diamond/Pearl. Secondly, Diamond/Pearl's third game, Platinum, outsold Ruby/Sapphire's third game, Emerald. The pattern is the same during the GB generation, only that generation sold the most yes. It goes GB > DS > GBA. So after a low point during the GBA generation, sales of the series went up during the DS generation. Personally, I don't see why it would decline again but that's besides the point. I have no agenda here, so I don't really care either way.

The actual problem is though, that the GBA didn't have a second main-line Pokémon game to compare Black/White to and thus also no third game to compare Black/White 2 to. Also, the remake on DS, Heartgold/Soulsilver, outsold the remake on GBA, thingy/thingy. Comparing X/Y pre-orders to Black/White pre-orders makes no sense in any way anyway.

The only really fair thing to do right now is compare X/Y pre-orders to Diamond/Pearl pre-orders, because they both have the same context, and draw your conclusions from there.