Mind-blow: Our choices are not pre-determined, but God knows

[happydolphin]

Nem said:

happydolphin said:

If we truly have free-will, then there is absolutely no pre-defined pattern as to why we chose this or that path in our lives. Your mind will be blown, but God's omniscience does not require logic: He is omniscient.

And that is where your argument breaks.

In other words you're saying: I dont know why this happens, therefore i pretend this just needs to happen regardlless. Its not different than saying: There is no logic in pigs flying... yet it doesnt require logic, its fantasy.

It most definitly doesnt make it real though.

Read the rest of the thread, I'm not denying conceptual logic, I'm defying pre-supposed logic. Read it as "God's omniscience does not follow regular logic." There is, I believe, in every theology, a trap. The trap here is to say that if God is omniscient, then he can predict your actions, which is simply logically impossible with free will.