Addressing The Argument That Japanese Developers Are Not As Good As Western

[MDMAlliance]

KylieDog said:

MDMAlliance said:

Really, the way you're rating these, what Western games are doing anything new or original if you don't include indie games?
You're bad at this.

Not at all, look at the GTA series, 2D top down on PS1, fully 3D on PS2, fully openworld and more featured world on PS3.  The dev took the new hardware each time and made massive advances each time.  Why are most JRPGs still using 2D non animated images for characters in dialogue like they did on PS1? 

If you can use GTA, why not use Zelda?  Started top down on the NES, turned fully 3D on the N64, motion controls (and I would add more if I played the game) on the Wii, and there may be yet another one of these innovations for the series in the one for Wii U.