By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
ultima said:

I'm too tired of you repeating your (a lot of times incoherent) arguments to say anything about Herod. How do you explain Luke's presentation of the census.

You may think we just went over it, but you did not show that it wasn't a contradiction.

That's not a satisfying explanation. Even if it were, it does not explain that in one case Judas buys a field with his money, in another he's so remorseful that he throws the money in the temple, and the priests use the money to buy a field.

Okay, good luck. Seriously. I spent 3 fucking hours explaining to you how you would have to be absolutetly conceited to consider the genealogy a contradiction.

@1. Incoherent arguments. What the hell are you talking about?

@3. It is a satisfying explanation, the money is a separate question altogether. Whether it was his field or not doesn't change the fact that he hung himself and exploded onto the field below. As for the money "contradiction" I don't know let me look it up........