My personal GOTY so far is Bioshock Infinite. Combat was fun, and the twisting, turning plot kept me intrigued right to the end (where everything twists even more).
I haven't played TLOU (not a PS3 owner), but I watched an entire playthrough on Youtube. It's a fantastic game, to be sure. The characters were more relatable in TLOU, though the ending (while well-crafted in its own right) didn't wow me like Bioshock's did. Gameplay-wise, TLOU is very stealth-oriented, which is NOT my cup of tea; I'm honestly not sure if I would have enjoyed TLOU more if I had played it, rather than just watching it.








