My The Last of Us impression (WARNING: possible spoilers!)

[Fifaguy360]

areason said:

Fifaguy360 said:

areason said:
your first two points as well as another contradict each other

No they don't. Infact they corroborate each other.

If the enemy AI do not respond to Ellie's stupid actions then they cancel each other out. 

They don't conveniently cancel each other out. They dampen the experience a bit. The first time I saw Tess crouch across an enemy, I held my breath, cursed at her then had a "lul wut?" moment when they didn't do anything.

Pretty sure Naughty Dog could have polished that up if they spent a bit more time on it.