By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
benao87 on 14 July 2013
Edit Thread
supermario128 said:
Vote: Benao

I'm pretty confident he was the one who killed me. Plus, he thinks me coming back " is a move that helped town a lot". Only mafia would assume I am town like that.

I'm not the first one that has you as a not mafia player, I didn't say you were town explicitly, just that you weren't a direct threat to town.

 

Final-Fan said:
Mario: can you explain further why you suspect benao?

Benao: can you explain further what exactly you mean by your first sentence in the above post? Do you mean that one of them was not notified of being scum at first and thus would have been acting 100% town during that time since they didn't even know they were scum? Or something else?

No, that's not what I meant. Rol theory about mafia being within a group of six people sounded like a good place to start at the beggining, and that's what I'm addressing, and that Rol himself has already replied to my statement about that particular theory.

RolStoppable said:
benao87 said:
As there are more than one member of mafia, I'd say that spurge could've started the game with only one checking in, so as vetteman did, the other one could be more than your initial suspects, thus I'd add at least astro and you to the possible mafia list.

Linkz being still alive could be a telling, but, without knowing roles, mafia could be still trying to hit by roles and not by players. Then, I can't still point fingers at him.

Must be directed at me.

It has already been pointed out yesterDay that my theory from Day 1 didn't hold water due to the memory issues of all players, the exception being v-man. astro was already among those initial suspects, so you aren't properly following the game. Which is further emphasized by the term "at least" you used, because it makes no sense to use it when you put both of the remaining replacements (radish and me; happyD is dead) on the list of suspects.

If roles are unknown, then the mafia usually tries to kill good players regardless of the roles they may have. So it's not like you said, but the other way around.

He was indded in the initial suspects, it's just that I wouldn't rule him out. He did hammered vetteman, but, lynching me would've resulted in a town flip, then he as a potential second member of mafia, would've been linked to vetteman, as the next possible lynch. Not suggesting that astro is mafia, just that I wouldn't put him as town.

Additionally, I never put radish as a suspect. With the at least I just left my statement open to include more suspects. I did include you, as there are no reason to believe you are not mafia.



Complete comic