My vote goes to Bioshock Infinite simply because of the brilliant, complex and unforgettable story. In my opinion it has one of the best stories in gaming history. It also kept me engaged the whole way through and the visuals and gameplay were both very ambitious. The only problem with the game is the replay value aspect because after 1 playthrough I don't feel like playing it any more. Portal 2 was also a great game but it wasn't at the same level of brilliance like Bioshock Infinite
Winner:
Bioshock Infinite







