Currently Online 
The Fury on 21 June 2013
Analog sticks being aligned is best in my opinion, makes more sense for both FPS (as stick are aligned, control in general is better, moving a thumb quickly to the buttons or d-pad to access other features is easy and consistent) and for fighters as, in this case the opposite where d-pad and buttons aligned for good control). As you can see I favour the DS3 over the 360s controller, trying to play Tekken on that thing is a joke.
That said the 360 controller for me was too big yet it seems that the Xbone controller is slightly smaller so might be suited better for me and if they have fixed the d-pad (left is not jump dang it, silly 360 controller) even better.
Hmm, pie.
