Mummelmann on 19 June 2013
The Witcher games, especially the second one, are easily the best on that list.
The first Dragon Age (Origins) is very good as well and Deus Ex: Human Revolution is terrific.
Dark Souls is hard as f***, Mass Effect 1 has massive sidequest and loading time issues, strange visuals and annoying voice acting and the sequel is pretty much a cover-based 3rd person shooter with watered down RPG elements and a run-of-the mill sci-fi plot (continued).
Never played KOTOR games.
Out of those, I'd say The Witcher 1 and 2, followed by Deus Ex and Dragon Age for a tie. One could argue that Deus Ex is just as action oriented as Mass Effect 2 but then again, it never pretended otherwise.
