| J_Allard said:
If you're buying equipment for a country club that only works at that country club then yes, it is tied to your membership. If you're banned from there, what happens to all of that equipment? It's worthless. |
Even if such equipment did exist, you could sell it to a member. So it wouldn't be worthless. Just another hole in kowenicki's analogy.
You can't make up a fictional scenario and then call it a spot on analogy. This topic is about losing your purchases if you are banned. In the real world I can be banned from a country club and keep my purchases. Who is going to join a country club where your clubs won't work on any other courses and you can't resell them freely? So how does this make for a good analogy?
Your argument seems to be morphing into making a fake country club with the same rules as an xbox one, and then saying it is a perfect analogy. Do you seriously not understand what is flawed with this?
A prison is just like a hotel if you were free to go at any time and had to pay for it. So they are basically identical. Spot on analogy.
