Munkeh111 said:
hasonap said:
pezus said:
hasonap said:
pezus said:
Still will never understand the GTAIV hate. Especially when one turns around and says he loves RDR o.O
This looks like a nice improvement over GTAIV.
There's always that one fucked up character in Rockstar games 
|
Well thats just my opinion, seeing as I loved every GTA until IV and then got into RDR(and L.A.Noire) and loved that I think the point stands. RDR is in my opinion a better executed game than IV and will always be so. You may not agree but this is my opinion you may disagree if you want to :)
|
I know it's just your opinion. I still won't ever understand it ;o. To me, RDR and GTAIV are basically based around the same exact ideas except the time period and characters are different. RDR did expand a bit on GTAIV's ideas, sure, but it ultimately uses very similar systems as GTAIV.
|
Storytelling and gameplay is a lot better in RDR than GTA IV. John Marston's vs Niko Bellick's story is a clear win for John
and for me who likes story more than anything else in open world games it stood out in comparison with IV
|
In what way did RDR not stand out? One of the best games I have ever played, maybe it didn't have the crazy fun of VC, SA etc, but the story was fantastic, the graphics also fantastic and the gameplay just felt fantastic. Who doesn't love being a cowboy
|
Wai what! I said that RDR stood out in comparison with IV not the other way around. I'm putting RDR over IV. If I would grade IV I would give it a stable 7.5 or 8 whereas I loved RDR and would give that more than a 8 every day.
