By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
pezus said:
hasonap said:
pezus said:

Still will never understand the GTAIV hate. Especially when one turns around and says he loves RDR o.O
This looks like a nice improvement over GTAIV.

There's always that one fucked up character in Rockstar games

Well thats just my opinion, seeing as I loved every GTA until IV and then got into RDR(and L.A.Noire) and loved that I think the point stands. RDR is in my opinion a better executed game than IV and will always be so. You may not agree but this is my opinion you may disagree if you want to :)

I know it's just your opinion. I still won't ever understand it ;o. To me, RDR and GTAIV are basically based around the same exact ideas except the time period and characters are different. RDR did expand a bit on GTAIV's ideas, sure, but it ultimately uses very similar systems as GTAIV.

Storytelling and gameplay is a lot better in RDR than GTA IV. John Marston's vs Niko Bellick's story is a clear win for John
 and for me who likes story more than anything else in open world games it stood out in comparison with IV