Is Nintendo even able or willing to surprise anymore?

[Osc89]

noname2200 said:

Osc89 said:

Well Sony made 12 90+ games for the PS3, whereas Nintendo only made 8 for the Wii. 5 of the PS3 games were new IP for this generation, while 0 of the Wii ones were. If Nintendo want to be known for having the best quality IPs, then they are going to have to do more than evolve the same formula.

You're using metacritic as the sole support for your argument.

Do you see where you went wrong?

What would you recommend I use to judge game quality then? Plus whatever you use to judge I doubt anyone can claim Nintendo brought more great new IP to the Wii than Sony did to the PS3.