I enjoyed Heavy Rain a little bit more because it had a better "villain" twist. Not gonna go into detail, but i was completely caught off guard by Heavy Rain and enjoyed the game way more than I ever hoped.
TWD was also an amazing experience. There were plenty of time when I got a case of the "feels." Even with it's cartoonish style,the characters felt human. However, i disliked the ending and "antagonist" reveal.
Both games were constantly making me want to finish with my RL duties so i could dive back in playing but in the end, Heavy Rain ending > TWD ending. I think what set these two games apart from the rest is that nobody expected them to be such great games.








