JRPG fans, why don't you.....

[Mad55]

Torillian said:

Mad55 said:

I never  once said the 360 was a better place for new ips more I showing that there's a good market for it and that the ps3 isn't some sure shot for good sales for jrpgs as some In This thread are saying. The original poster who I was quoting acted as If the ps3 would have made the lost odyssey sell better back then and that wasn't a fact but a possibility.

No prediction based on hypothetical scenarios this complex is ever really fact, but he has the most evidence behind his argument unless you assume that Sony would not have put up the ad campaign that MS did which is a reasonable probability but not what you presented.  

Yes, he was wrong in the idea that it definitely would have sold better had it been on PS3 but you were wrong in your justification "considering alot of the the new rpgs ips relased exclusively on 360 sold better than the new ones on ps3 imma have to say that its in no way absolute that it would have sold better on ps3." because you arne't comparing apples to apples with your "a lot of the new RPGs IPs released sold better"  The only apples to apples comparisons for rpg fanbase sales have been in favor of the PS3, so assuming that it got the same ad campaign I think the most likely answer is it would have sold better.  

No he did not hve the most evidence. Aslo 2 bolded im comparing jpgs to jrpgs that is apples to apples. But its all good well never agree lol.