Gamespot scores Luigi's mansion 6.5

[pokoko]

Chandler said:

pokoko said:
Ah, personal attacks because someone gave a game a somewhat negative review. Lovely.

As for her not being a good gamer, she gave the PC version of Dark Souls a 9.5 (and Nintendoland a 8.0) so I'm willing to give her the benefit of the doubt.

Now THAT is really strange. I guess she played Dark Souls in jolly co-operation otherwise I have to conclude that Luigi's Mansion is harder than Dark Souls.

Not to argue someone else's opinions--only they can do that--there is a difference between frustrating and challenging, especially when it comes to game mechanics.  Also, I don't think Dark Souls and Luigi's Mansion are supposed to be played with the same purposes in mind.

I can't speak about the objective parts, but from reading the review, having to redo solved puzzles because you die really does deserve to have points subtracted, if it's true.  I hate when games make you do that.