Nintendo Fans: how do you expect the most anticipated Wii U titles to sell?

[scottie]

curl-6 said:

scottie said:
the (presumably joking) response that Zelda, if cartooney) will sell less than windwaker did.

I wasn't joking.

The "core" want a dark, semi-realistic Zelda. (Think Twilight Princess) Why do you think the E3 2011 demo got so much positive hype? Numerous gamers who would otherwise never touch a Wii U would run out and buy one to play a dark Zelda in HD.

If Zelda U is cartoony, these same gamers will run for the hills.

That didn't justify your point. That justified why you think A cartoony Zelda on the WiiU would sell less than Twilight Princess.

 

Why would a cartoony Zelda on the Gamecube outsell a cartoony Zelda on the WiiU?