By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Kytiara said:
The wiki page just re-inforces what I meant at the very end of my last post. The answer is much more complicated than just saying 0.999... = 1, the key being the concept of limits

 Kind of true.

1)  0.999...  is a notation.  It, by definition, MEANS there's an infinite number of "9"s after the decimal point.

2)  Once you accept that, 0.999... = 1.  There is a gazillion proofs out there, the wiki page has a good collection of them.

On the concept of "infinity": it is by no means an intuitive concept.  The ancient Greeks for instance could not come to grips with it--Zeno's paradox, for instance.

As to 0.999... :  If you know "real analysis", or "analysis" for short, you'd know the history of it.  It took a few centuries and some very brilliant mathematicians to lay out the foundations!  It shouldn't be a surprise that without formal training people would be arguing over it over and over and over ...

 

P.S.  Amount of "formal training": for the typical math student, he/she gets some exposure to real analysis in high school calculus.  In college, typically there are 4 semesters of calculus (AP Calculus BC can place you out of the first 2 semesters typically, but it depends on the curriculum).  A solid Real analysis is typically a junior/senior level course (2 semesters), a core requisite for math majors.  However, most PhD level physical scientists and engineers are highly recommended to have a solid understanding of it.

 



the Wii is an epidemic.