What will be the first console game of 2013 to score a 90+ Metacritic?

[walsufnir]

pokoko said:
GTAV, on the other hand, is a GTA game, which reviewers seem to absolutely adore. I've never seen a series where reviewers are so willing to ignore flaws. So, yeah, that gets my vote.

What is wrong with the GTAs? Where are the flaws?