The bans in Jaywood's thread are laudable

[TruckOSaurus]

thismeintiel said:

J_Allard said:
Yeah I understand that's what he meant. The two situations are not the same. Nor are threads about sales accomplishments. You guys wanna find a comparable PS3 thread for future ban bickering, think of a PS+ thread or something. Like you post a thread about Red Dead Redemption finally being free on PS+. Someone replies saying "LOL its 2013 get with the times Steam does everything PS+ does for free" or "FREE LOL" or "anything more than $0 for this service is too much"... those are the type of stupid, irrelevant replies that got people banned in that thread.

Debating the merits of a GOTY award or the importance of some sales accomplishment are not the same thing. I think you guys will be sorely disappointed.

If this is the new precedent , then you are wrong.  If you go into a pro-Sony thread or a GOTY thread, where the OP doesn't specifically ask for the opposing sides input, and start talking about Sony's financials or how you think that game is overrated , then you can be moderated if someone reports you.

I can see bringing up Sony's financials being off topic but saying the game is overrated is very much on topic since we're talking about a game that's supposed to be better than all the others during the year.