By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
happydolphin said:
Chrizum said:

Yes. God made me with free will. Irregardless of whatever it is I choose in the future. I accept that. Now, even though his knowledge about my choice isn't the basis of my creation, he still knows my choices, right? Like, hypothethically, if I were to ask God, and if he had to answer truthfully, he would say to me that he knows which choice I'm going to make. Do you agree or disagree with this?

Yes, he would. (I agree with you)

Okay. So, logically, there is no way I can choose A now, as God already knows I'd choose B. While I feel I have a choice, as I can choose A or B, that choice in reality is an illusion, because the only possible outcome is B. Now, I'm not saying God has determined that I will choose B. He may not have influenced the scenario at all. But my "choice" is predetermined. Free will is an illusion.